Most of use are familiar with the famous Blues Hog BBQ Sauce, but we discovered a couple of years ago that they also
sell lump charcoal. So, it's about time that we review this charcoal
and see what it's all about! There isn't
a whole lot of information available on this charcoal except that it is made from Missouri hardwoods, Oak, Hickory
and Maple. (For your convenience, we include a map of the US at right showing the location of Missouri.)
It is almost certainly made by one of the few remaining companies in Missouri still making lump
charcoal, but nonetheless, let's see how it did.
We purchased this charcoal from Ace Hardware, so it was rather pricey, about $4.00 more per bag on the Ace web site than
is listed on the Blues Hog web site. Our local Ace Hardware carries this charcoal in the store, and is $2.00 cheaper than
is listed on the Ace Hardware national web site. So, your mileage may vary when it comes to price.
So let's open the bag and take a look. The first thing we noticed was the lack of very many large pieces and quite
a large amount of small pieces. Upon sorting the bag, we found the following mix of sizes:
Large |
1.0 pounds |
4.8% |
Medium |
3.7 pounds |
17.1% |
Small |
14.2 pounds |
66.1% |
Chips/Dust |
2.6 pounds |
12.0% |
|
|
|
Total |
21.5 pounds |
|
|
As you can see, the mix of sizes was pretty disappointing. The quantity of chips and dust at 12% was only
Average, and the 66.1% of small pieces was enormous. Only 22% of the bag consisted of large or medium size pieces.
The manufacturer should really be screening this charcoal better and ensuring a better distribution of
sizes. The good news from our inspection is that the bag contained no scrap or any other odd materials.
We did find three pieces of uncarbonized bark, but there is nothing wrong with that.
So, on to our lighting test. This charcoal was very easy to light taking only 2.5 sheets of newspapar to
get a fire going in our chimney starter. There was no popping and very little sparking while the charcoal
was being lit. The charcoal has the familiar smell when burning of the US hardwoods that go into this charcoal.
The smoke was moderately strong.
Next, in our maximum temperature test, Blues Hog charcoal reached a searing 990°F which is Very High
compared to all other brands of charcoal we have tested. While coming up to temperature, again there was
no popping and very little sparking. The fire spread relatively quickly.
In our burntime time test, Blues Hog charcoal burned a very long time—in the top 15% of all the brands
we have tested. Needless to say this is Very High compared to all brands we have tested. We light the charcoal
for our burntime test with a MAP-Pro™ torch. Using a torch almost always produces a lot of sparking and popping
but in this case, the amount was moderate. Regardless, always take appropriate precautions when using a torch
to light charcoal.
Finally, in our ash test, the amount of ash produced by Blues Hog was Low compared to all other brands.
So in summary, we have a charcoal that does very well in many areas, scoring five stars in lighting, maximum
temperature, and burntime, and four stars in ash production. Even the amount of chips and dust was no worse
than average, but the overall distribution of sizes was very disappointing with two-thirds of the bag being
small pieces. It's hard to give a top grade to a product that calls itself premium and charges a premium
price, when it could be better if the manufacturer just screened
the charcoal better. As a result, we can only give Blues Hog charcoal our Recommended rating.